Our visit to a local Alliance church last Sunday morning (a friend of mine from work became a Christian last year and invited us to hear him give his testimony) reminded us of how important it is to have and maintain the right songs in worship. Their "worship" music was repetitive lyrics, void of Biblical content, coupled with loud energy and rhythm designed to move the body ahead of the mind.
In 1876,
R.L. Dabney, speaking against the popular gospel songs of his day, wrote: "we shall in the end have a mass of corrupting religious poetry against which the church will have to wage a sore contest." The danger, Dabney warned, "is that of habituating the taste of Christians to a very vapid species of pious doggerel, containing the most diluted possible traces of saving truth, suitable to the most infantile faculties, supplemented by a jingle of vain repetitions." Ouch! How much more does Dabney's warning apply to us in 2005! (Quoted in "
With Reverence and Awe: Returning to the Basics of Reformed Worship" by D.G. Hart & J.R. Muether.)
According to Hart and Muether, "Worship music is threatening to undo the one trait that has always characterized Reformed worship, namely, the centrality of the Word." (pg 174)